Dear Sir,
I have never heard of a tinder party, but you gave it a shot. After weeks of texting, adding me on Facebook (see warning in post 1), and both being too busy we meet.
You gave me a call around 2:00 PM on a Wednesday and invited me over for wine. Coincidentally I'm in your neck of the uptown woods. You attempt to reassure me by saying you have a friend over so I won't be murdered. FYI I think I stand a better chance fighting one man rather than 2. I protest briefly, because I'm in the middle of my work day, but agree to come over afterwards. Unless you're paying my rent, work comes first.
I saunter on over to Central Park South after my work excursion, make my way through the myriad of tourists and prep myself for the best/worst. A girl answers the door. If I had a crystal ball and knew what the next 2 hours would entail I would have known why this girl (we'll dub her White Candy, because she expressed enthusiasm for it) seemed squeamish and unapproachable as I ask if you're home and introduce myself enthusiastically.
We both walk out to the balcony where you and a friend have clearly been imbibing for hours. At this juncture you announce that you have met both of us via Tinder. I find this hysterical and silently applaud you/write you off for being so outrageous. White Candy did not seem so amused. Let's called her reaction hot and bothered.
As we continue this charade you begin to award each girl points for certain actions. Game on. I do not regard myself as a particularly competitive person. This is a result of wining at the game of life. The point game was funny until my "competition" asks if the attempted toss of a hockey puck wins her points. Aw.
I have a party I to go to, not to mention a Grouper stand in following that, so I make moves back downtown. Before I leave I use your restroom one last time. 4 beers in an hour and a half will getcha. Knock knock on the bathroom door. Time to try and snag the winning tinder? Looks like it. I react to an aggressive make out attempt in 2 ways, which are situational of course. 1. Join in for obvious reasons. 2. Push back and thwart ALL attempts. I went halfsies on 2. As unbearable as the girl was, I don't want to be the root of drama as I'm making a swift exit.
I leave and text you, "I won." I got an "I love you" response. Point.
Yesterday made for a good story and some dropped jaws over cocktails afterwards, but it would take a weekend away to Paris to convince me to put another minute into you.
Good luck with White Candy. I think y'all have a real future.
xoxo
BWinTBC